Concussion Sub Rule, IND Vs Eng 4th T20: Ruckus on Concisition Substitute Rule, Jose Butler Team Rage on India … Why did 12th man Harshit Rana replace Inzard Shivam Dubey? – Concussion Sub Substute Control Controversy Ind vs Eng 4th T20I JOS Buttler Gets Angry at Team India Why 12th Man Harshit Rana Rana Rana Rana Rana Rana Rana Replace Injured Shivam DuBe Full Story TSPok
Jos buttler on conduction sub rule: ‘Either Shivam Dubey has increased the speed of 25 mph with the ball or Harshit (Rana) has really improved his batting’. Actually these emotions were of England captain Jose Butler after losing to the Indian team in Pune T20. Those who were angry at the Shivam Dubey place to be seen as a conversion substitute. At the same time, the Diggj Khiladis of England, who are commenting, also raised questions on this regia.
India’s move to replace Shivam Dubey during the fourth T20 match against England in Pune has been criticized for India’s move. After the match, England captain Jose Butler said that it does not fit in the definition of LIKE-For-Like Replacement. On air television commentator Kevin Peterson and Nick Knight also raised questions on this change. Were. Dubey did not land on the ground after getting hurt on the helmet while scoring 53 runs off 34 balls.
𝗪𝗛𝗔𝗧. 𝗔. 𝗪𝗜𝗡!#Teamindia Held their composure & seled a 1⃣5⃣-run victory in the 4th t20i to bag the series, with a game to spare!
Scorecard ▶ ️ #INDVENG , @IDFCFIRSTBank pic.twitter.com/jjz5cem2us
– BCCI (@Bcci) January 31, 2025
Butler said after India’s 15-run win- this is not the same substitute, we do not agree with this, either Shivam Dubey has increased the speed of about 25 mph with the ball or Harshit really in his batting Has improved It is part of the game and we should actually win the match, but we disagree with this decision.
Butler further said- no consultation was taken with us. When I came to bat, I was thinking this, in whose place Harshit is placed? He said that it is a conversion replacement, from which I was clearly disagreeed, it is not a similar replacement. He said that the match referee had decided. We did not have any role in this or in any part of it, but we will ask Jawagal (Srinath) some questions to get clarity about this.
Dubey scored 57 runs, this is like this
Dubey scored a half -century after falling 4 wickets for 57 runs and partnered 87 runs for the sixth wicket with Hardik Pandya. Due to which India could score 181 runs for 9 wickets. On the last ball of the innings, Dubey’s helmet hit the ball at a speed of 141.5 kmph of Jamie overton. India had batting all -rounder Ramandeep Singh on the bench, which could have been a better option for Dubey. Ramandeep came to the field for some time to field for Varun Chakraborty.
Kevin Peterson also raised questions
Peterson said on air commentary- he (Rana) is not the right option for Shivam Dubey, you ask anyone in the world, and they will say the same. Dubey is not a real pacer, but Rana is. Nick Knight also repeated the same thing.
Morne Morkel told why Team India did this
Morne Morkel, assistant coach of Team India, said- Shivam went out of the field with a mild headache symptoms in the innings break. We sent a name to the match referee for the suitable conversion substitute, and the match referee was to take a decision from there. When the decision was taken, the joy was eating food, so we had to read him as soon as possible to go to the field and bowl. This is in the hands of the people sitting on me, the match referee decides in it. We can only push the name forward and after that things get out of our hands.
For his vital half-textury, Shivam dube badged the player of the match award in the fourth #INDVENG T20i.
Scorecard ▶ ️ #Teamindia , @IDFCFIRSTBank pic.twitter.com/rmbxyog0mo
– BCCI (@Bcci) January 31, 2025
Debumen Rana bowled in 12th over
Harshit Rana, who was playing his first T20 International, was brought on a balling attack in the 12th over and he dismissed Liam Livingstone on his second ball. Rana threw his entire overs and took three wickets. At the same time, Rana also caught England captain Jose Butler on Short Thirdman, who went back angrily and he spoke some things to Head Coach Brendon McCullum, maybe he was not happy with Rana about the consulting substitute.
Consideration subscriber came to know after 2 overs: Rana
After the match, Harshit Rana said- after two overs, I was told (about being a conversion substitute). I was waiting for this moment (my debut) to prove myself. When I got a chance, I did not think about the signs and just thought about performing well, I have the experience of bowling in the death overs (for KKR in IPL) and I trusted him.
What is the conversion substitute rule?
According to the ICC, if any Khiladi’s head or eye injuries occur in the conversion substitute, the new player can be included as a replacement. For example, if there is an all -rounder conversion substitute, then the team can be included in the match that is in the match. However, there should be a substance like for likes (uniform). This is clarified in Claus 1.2.7.3.4 of the rule. Can Harshit Rana be described as the conversion option of Shivam Dubey? Because Harshit is basically a bowler, Shivam is a batting all -rounder.
